🖌️ Should I Paint or Replace My Kitchen Cabinets? Pros, Cons & Cost Breakdown

If your kitchen feels outdated or worn, your cabinets are likely the first place your eyes go. But when it comes time for an upgrade, many homeowners ask:

“Should I paint or replace my kitchen cabinets?”
Let’s break it down with real numbers, pros and cons, and expert insight from Sunshine Pro Paints in Jacksonville, Florida.

💸 Cost Comparison: Painting vs. Replacing Cabinets in Jacksonville

OptionAverage Cost (10'x10' Kitchen)Time FramePainting Cabinets$1,200 – $3,0003–5 daysReplacing Cabinets$8,000 – $20,000+2–4 weeks (or more)

Painting your existing cabinets can save you thousands—while still delivering a fresh, modern look.

🎨 Benefits of Painting Your Cabinets

• ✅ Cost-effective upgrade

• ✅ Quick transformation without a major remodel

• ✅ Minimal disruption to your kitchen

• ✅ Wide variety of colors and finishes

• ✅ Can boost home value and appeal

With professional prep and paint (like we offer at Sunshine Pro Paints), your cabinets can look brand new and last 5–10 years or more.

🔨 When Replacing Might Be the Better Option

• ❌ Structural damage (warping, mold, water damage)

• ❌ Outdated cabinet layout or poor storage design

• ❌ Low-quality materials that won’t hold up to new paint

• ❌ Planning a full kitchen remodel with layout changes

If your cabinets are beyond repair, replacement may be necessary—but it’s often overkill for cabinets in decent shape.

🛠️ What About Cabinet Refacing?

Cabinet refacing is a middle-ground option that replaces only doors and drawer fronts. It can cost $4,000–$9,000, depending on materials—but still costs more than painting and doesn’t offer the same color flexibility.

👩‍🎨 Real Clients, Real Savings

Many of our Jacksonville clients have saved over $10,000 by choosing to paint instead of replace their cabinets. One client told us:

“I thought I needed new cabinets. Sunshine Pro Paints made mine look better than new—at a fraction of the cost!”

🏡 Our Expert Opinion

Unless your cabinets are damaged or you want to redesign the kitchen layout, painting is the smarter choice. It’s budget-friendly, efficient, and can completely elevate your kitchen.

🎯 Thinking About Painting Your Cabinets?

Sunshine Pro Paints specializes in premium cabinet painting in Jacksonville, FL. We use top-tier products, precision prep work, and a professional spray finish that lasts.

📞 Get a free quote today and let’s transform your kitchen—without breaking the bank.